Through Hole vs Surface Mount: Which is better?

In the world of electronics, the quality and reliability of PCB mounting is essential for the performance and longevity of devices. Whether in everyday gadgets, medical devices, or industrial machinery, the mounting process ensures that the electronic components are securely attached to the PCB to create functional circuits. This guide explores the two most common PCB mounting techniques, Surface Mount Technology (SMT) and Through-Hole Technology (THT), along with the best practices to ensure optimal results for your PCB assembly projects.

What is PCB Mounting?

PCB mounting refers to the process of attaching electronic components to a printed circuit board (PCB). This ensures the components, like resistors, capacitors, and integrated circuits, are correctly placed and connected to create a functional electrical circuit. The choice of mounting technology can significantly impact the performance, size, cost, and complexity of the final product.

Common PCB Mounting Techniques: Through-Hole vs Surface Mount

There are two primary techniques for mounting components to printed circuit boards: Surface Mount Technology (SMT) and Through-Hole Technology (THT). Each has its strengths and is suitable for different applications. Understanding the differences between through-hole and surface mount is essential for making the right choice for your design and manufacturing needs.

Surface Mount Technology 

Surface Mount Technology (SMT) is a modern PCB assembly technique where components, known as surface mount devices (SMDs), are mounted directly onto the surface of the PCB. The components are soldered using SMT solder to create a solid electrical connection. Here's a closer look at the SMT process:

1. Component Placement:
   
   • SMDs are placed on the surface of the PCB using automated pick-and-place machines, which provide high precision and efficiency.
   • SMT assembly is ideal for mass production because the machines can place components at high speeds.
2. Solder Paste Application:
   
   • Solder paste is applied to the PCB’s pads using stencils or screen printing.
   • This paste will later help in bonding the component leads to the PCB when heated.
3. Reflow Soldering:
   
   • The assembled PCB is passed through a reflow oven, where the solder melts and forms a strong connection between the SMT component and the PCB.
   • This step ensures reliable electrical connections and mechanical bonding.

Advantages of SMT:

• Compact Design: Surface mount PCBs allow for high-density designs with smaller components, making them perfect for portable and miniaturized devices.
• Lower Manufacturing Costs: Automated processes, like SMT assembly, reduce labor costs and improve production speed, especially for high-volume manufacturing.
• Better Electrical Performance: With shorter electrical paths, SMT components can improve performance, especially in high-frequency applications.

Through-Hole Technology (THT)

Through-hole technology (THT) involves inserting component leads through holes in the PCB. This method is often preferred for components that require strong mechanical support or need to endure physical stress, such as connectors, switches, and power components. Here's how the through-hole process works:

1. Component Insertion:
   
   • Through-hole components are inserted into pre-drilled holes in the PCB. These holes are typically created during the PCB fabrication process.
   • The components are aligned and secured through the hole, providing a robust bond.
2. Soldering:
   
   • Once the components are in place, their leads are soldered to the pads on the opposite side of the board, often using wave soldering or manual soldering techniques.
   • Solder is applied to ensure a reliable electrical connection.

Advantages of THT:

• Mechanical Strength: The through-hole mount creates a strong physical bond, making it suitable for applications where components must endure vibrations or stress.
• Easier to Repair: Through-hole boards allow for easier replacement or repair of components, which is crucial in prototyping or testing phases.

Through Hole vs Surface Mount: The Differences

When comparing SMT with THT, there are several key factors to consider:

• Size and Density:
  
  • SMT components are generally smaller, allowing for high-density designs.
  • Through-hole boards are typically larger and better suited for heavy-duty components.
• Manufacturing Speed:
  
  • SMT assembly is faster and more cost-effective for high-volume production.
  • THT is more labor-intensive and used primarily for specific applications that require strong mechanical strength.
• Mechanical Support:
  
  • Through-hole mounts provide superior mechanical support, making them ideal for components that experience physical stress or require durability in harsh environments.

Mixed Technology: Combining SMT and THT

In many modern applications, mixed technology is used, which involves a combination of both SMT and THT. This hybrid approach allows designers to benefit from the strengths of both techniques. For instance, in automotive electronics, surface mount to through hole adapters might be used to combine the compactness of SMT components with the mechanical robustness of through-hole components.

This combination is often seen in surface mount assemblies where high-density circuits for smaller components coexist with through-hole boards for larger, more rugged components such as connectors, power supplies, or switches. This ensures that both performance and durability are optimized.

PCB Mounting Methods

There are several methods used to assemble components on the PCB, whether using SMT, THT, or a combination of both.

• Manual Assembly:
  
  • Involves skilled technicians placing and soldering components by hand.
  • This method allows for precision and flexibility but is slower and prone to human error.
• Automated Assembly:
  
  • Automated processes like pick-and-place machines for placing SMDs and soldering robots for reflow or wave soldering improve speed, accuracy, and consistency.
• Selective Soldering:
  
  • Used primarily for THT components. It involves soldering specific areas of the PCB while leaving other regions untouched.
  • This method is ideal for through-hole mount components that require careful soldering.

Best Practices for PCB Mounting

To achieve the best results in PCB mounting, it's important to follow best practices that ensure reliability and efficiency:

• Design for Manufacturability (DFM):
  
  • Ensure your PCB design allows for easy mounting and minimizes assembly challenges.
  • Proper spacing between components reduces the risk of solder bridges, overheating, and mechanical failures.
• Component Selection:
  
  • Choose the right components for your design, keeping in mind factors like size, temperature ratings, and environmental conditions.
  • For example, THT components may be better suited for applications that require high mechanical strength, while SMDs are ideal for compact designs.
• Soldering Techniques:
  
  • Use appropriate soldering techniques for SMD soldering and through-hole mount components.
  • Ensure proper application of solder paste for SMT assembly and good lead preparation for THT components to prevent poor solder joints.
• Testing and Inspection:
  
  • Conduct thorough testing and inspection after the mounting process.
  • Automated Optical Inspection (AOI) and X-ray inspection are essential to detect issues such as misaligned components, solder bridges, or poor solder connections.
• Documentation:
  
  • Maintain detailed records of the mounting process for traceability and future assembly reference.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Despite following best practices, some common mistakes can compromise the quality of PCB mounting:

• Incorrect Component Orientation:
  
  • Ensure all components, especially polarized components, are mounted in the correct orientation to avoid failure.
• Inadequate or Excess Solder:
  
  • Insufficient solder can result in weak connections, while too much solder can lead to short circuits. Proper soldering technique is essential for consistent quality.
• Ignoring Thermal Management:
  
  • Overheating components during soldering can damage sensitive parts.
  • Always follow recommended thermal profiles to avoid damage.

Conclusion

Choosing the right PCB mounting technique, whether through hole or surface mount, is crucial for the performance, durability, and manufacturability of your electronic device. SMT is ideal for high-density, compact designs, while THT provides robust mechanical support for components that experience stress or vibrations. Mixed technology, combining both techniques, offers flexibility, allowing for optimal designs that cater to both electrical performance and mechanical strength.

By following best practices and avoiding common mistakes, you can ensure that your surface mount assembly or through-hole board meets the highest standards of quality, reliability, and performance

You might also like:

• Cold Solder Joints Explained: How to Spot and Fix Them
• A Beginner’s Guide to Vias in PCB Design
• What is Magic Smoke and What Causes It?
• ESP8266: A Beginner’s Guide to All Things ESP
• Understanding Schematic Diagrams in PCB Design