Through-Hole Technology: Why It Still Matters in Modern PCB Design

In this article, we'll delve into why through-hole technology still matters in modern PCB design, exploring its core principles, advantages, applications, and the reasons behind its persistent value in the electronics industry.

What is Through-Hole Technology?

At its core, through-hole technology is a method where electronic components are mounted on PCBs by inserting pins or leads through holes drilled into the board. Once inserted, these leads are soldered from the opposite side, creating a stable mechanical and electrical connection. This technique has been vital for component reliability, especially in applications requiring high durability and mechanical strength.

A Brief History of Through-Hole Technology

Through-hole technology's roots trace back to the 1940s, a pioneering period where the first printed circuit boards were developed. Initially, the process involved manually drilling holes in PCB material and soldering components on one side, a labor-intensive method that emphasized the ingenuity and resourcefulness of early electronics engineers.

As technology evolved, so did PCB design, transitioning from single-sided to double-sided boards and eventually to multilayer configurations, expanding the scope for through-hole applications.

Common Through-Hole Components

Through-hole technology relies on components with leads (or terminals) designed to be inserted into drilled holes on a printed circuit board (PCB). These leads are then soldered to pads on the opposite side of the board, creating a strong mechanical and electrical connection. Some of the most commonly encountered through-hole components include:

• Resistors: These components restrict the flow of electrical current and are essential for setting voltage levels and limiting current in circuits. They are easily identifiable by their color-coded bands that indicate their resistance value and tolerance.
• Capacitors: Capacitors store electrical energy and are used for filtering, decoupling, and timing circuits. Through-hole capacitors come in various types, including electrolytic (polarized), ceramic, and film capacitors, each with different characteristics and applications.
• Diodes: Diodes allow current to flow in only one direction and are used for rectification, signal processing, and voltage regulation. Common through-hole diode types include rectifier diodes, Zener diodes, and LEDs (Light Emitting Diodes).
• Transistors: Transistors are semiconductor devices that act as electronic switches or amplifiers. Through-hole transistors are commonly found in bipolar junction transistor (BJT) and field-effect transistor (FET) configurations.
• Integrated Circuits (ICs): While many modern ICs are surface-mount, through-hole ICs, particularly older or larger packages like DIP (Dual In-line Package), are still used. These ICs contain complex circuitry and perform a wide range of functions.
• Connectors: Through-hole connectors provide a means to connect PCBs to other circuits or devices. Examples include pin headers, terminal blocks, and various types of edge connectors.
• Inductors/Coils: Inductors store energy in a magnetic field when current flows through them. They are used in filtering circuits, power supplies, and radio frequency (RF) applications.

While surface-mount technology has become dominant, through-hole components remain relevant due to their robustness, ease of prototyping, and suitability for certain applications.

Through-Hole Assembly Process

Assembling circuits using through-hole technology involves a distinct process compared to surface-mount technology. Here's a breakdown of the typical steps:

Component Preparation

This step involves preparing the components for insertion. This might include bending or trimming the leads to the correct length and shape to fit the PCB layout. Some components, like resistors, may come pre-bent for easier insertion.

Component Placement

Components are manually inserted into the appropriate holes on the PCB. This requires careful attention to component orientation and polarity (for components like electrolytic capacitors and diodes). Pick-and-place machines can automate this process for some components, but manual placement is still common.

Lead Securing (Optional)

In some cases, especially when wave soldering is used, the leads might be temporarily secured to the PCB before soldering. This can be done by bending the leads on the solder side of the board to prevent components from falling out during the soldering process. Specialized component retaining clips or adhesive dots may also be used.

Soldering

This is the most critical step, creating the electrical and mechanical connection between the component leads and the PCB pads. Two primary soldering methods are used:

• Wave Soldering: The assembled PCB is passed over a wave of molten solder. The solder adheres to the exposed leads and pads, creating a strong connection. This method is suitable for boards with a large number of through-hole components.
• Manual Soldering: A technician uses a soldering iron to individually solder each lead to its corresponding pad. This method is more time-consuming but offers greater control and is ideal for low-volume production, prototyping, or rework/repair.

Lead Trimming

After soldering, the excess length of the component leads on the solder side of the PCB is trimmed to prevent short circuits and ensure proper clearance. Specialized lead cutters are used for this task.

Cleaning

The PCB may be cleaned to remove any solder flux residue. Flux residue can be corrosive or conductive and can negatively affect the long-term reliability of the circuit. Cleaning can be done using solvents or aqueous cleaning solutions.

Inspection and Testing

The assembled PCB is thoroughly inspected to ensure that all components are correctly placed, oriented, and soldered. Electrical testing is performed to verify the functionality of the circuit.

Advantages of Through-Hole Technology

Through-hole technology carries several benefits that make it appealing for certain applications:

1. Mechanical Strength and Durability: Through-hole components provide a stronger mechanical connection to the PCB than SMT components. The leads passing through the board and being soldered on the opposite side create a robust bond, making them more resistant to physical stress and vibration. This makes THT suitable for applications in harsh environments or where reliability is critical.
2. Higher Power Handling Capacity: Through-hole components generally manage higher voltages and currents than smaller components due to their larger physical footprint.
3. Ease of Prototyping and Repair: Through-hole components are generally easier to handle and solder manually than SMT components. This makes them ideal for prototyping, hobbyist projects, and small-batch production. Repairing or replacing a through-hole component is also simpler, as the larger leads are easier to access and solder.
4. Lower Cost for Some Components: While SMT components are generally cheaper in mass production, some specific through-hole components might be more readily available and cost-effective in smaller quantities.

Drawbacks of Through-Hole Technology

Despite its advantages, through-hole technology is not without its challenges:

1. Lower Component Density: THT components take up more space on the PCB compared to surface-mount components. This limits the component density that can be achieved, making it less suitable for miniaturized designs.
2. Higher Manufacturing Costs: The assembly process for THT is generally more labor-intensive, particularly for component placement and lead trimming. This can lead to higher manufacturing costs, especially for large-volume production.
3. Longer Assembly Times: Manual insertion of components into the holes is slower than automated SMT placement. Wave soldering, while faster than manual soldering, is still typically slower than reflow soldering used in SMT.
4. Limited Design Flexibility: The larger size and lead configurations of THT components can limit the design flexibility of the circuit board layout.

Applications of Through-Hole Technology

Despite the rise of surface-mount technology (SMT), through-hole technology (THT) maintains a robust presence across various industries due to its reliability, ease of prototyping, and suitability for handling larger, more robust components. Here are some notable applications:

• Automotive: Through-hole components are frequently employed in automotive control systems, such as engine control units (ECUs) and anti-lock braking systems (ABS), where reliability under harsh conditions (temperature extremes, vibration) is paramount. They are also found in infotainment systems, particularly in power supply and audio amplifier circuits.
• Healthcare: THT is commonly used in critical medical devices like patient monitors, diagnostic equipment (e.g., EKG machines), and infusion pumps. The durability and ease of repair associated with through-hole components are especially valued in medical settings where equipment downtime can have serious consequences.
• Industrial Machinery: Through-hole components are prevalent in industrial control systems, such as Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs), motor drives, and power supplies for industrial equipment. Their robustness makes them well-suited for the demanding environments often found in factories and manufacturing plants.
• Consumer Electronics: While SMT dominates the consumer electronics landscape, THT components are still integrated into certain devices. Examples include audio amplifiers (especially high-power amplifiers), power supplies for various devices, and in some legacy or specialized equipment.

Conclusion

Through-hole technology, a foundational element of PCB design since the earliest days of electronics, continues to offer enduring value despite the prevalence of surface-mount technology. THT's robustness, reliability, and ease of prototyping make it indispensable across industries like automotive, healthcare, and industrial machinery.

Recognizing the unique advantages of through-hole technology enables engineers and designers to create optimal solutions for diverse applications. While SMT excels in miniaturization and automation, THT's mechanical strength ensures it remains a valuable tool in the electronics manufacturing landscape, coexisting with SMT to meet the ever-evolving demands of modern electronics.

You might also like:

• Cold Solder Joints Explained: How to Spot and Fix Them
• A Beginner’s Guide to Vias in PCB Design
• What is Magic Smoke and What Causes It?
• ESP8266: A Beginner’s Guide to All Things ESP
• Understanding Schematic Diagrams in PCB Design